An old address still opens, but you want people to use a newer page. Before choosing canonical vs redirect behavior, decide whether the old address should remain usable or send the visitor elsewhere. A search signal and a navigation change answer different requirements.

Start by asking what should happen when a person opens the old or alternate address. Should they stay there, or should the site send them somewhere else?

A duplicate version can still be usable

Consider a sample product page available through an ordinary address and a campaign-parameter address. The alternate URL may still need to load the product, while search signals point toward the preferred page.

Google's canonicalization guidance describes methods for indicating a preferred URL and how search evaluates those signals. A canonical reference does not make a visitor's browser automatically navigate to the referenced address.

Use the actual content relationship to choose the preferred version. A canonical pointing to an unrelated page is not a useful substitute for resolving mismatched or obsolete content.

A moved page needs a navigation decision

If a page has moved and the old address should send visitors to the new one, a suitable redirect expresses that behavior. Check the redirect type and the intended permanence with the site's implementation requirements.

Follow the old URL as a visitor would. Does it reach the right destination? Is there an unnecessary chain? Does it preserve parameters that the destination actually needs? A redirect that lands on a generic homepage can be a poor experience when a relevant replacement exists.

Avoid changing either canonical tags or redirects from a spreadsheet alone. Review what the old and new pages contain and why their relationship justifies the change.

Meta Tags Analyzer can inspect supported metadata in supplied HTML. Use it to review canonical values, then check the live page through the appropriate site-review process. Pasted markup and served markup can differ.

URL Encoder and Decoder can help inspect encoded components when a query value looks confusing. It does not decide whether a parameter is safe to discard or configure a server redirect.

For the campaign example, keep the landing page usable if that is the intended visitor behavior, and review the preferred search URL separately. For a real move, test the old address and the destination directly. Document the reason for the choice so a future editor does not replace a functioning redirect with a tag that merely looks similar in an SEO checklist.